Why hunt fowl?

As part of the Between Islands project, Shetland’s new online exhibition, ‘Fair Game’ examines three customs that are now sometimes viewed rather emotively – fowling, whaling and peat cutting. Here, curator Ian Tait takes a closer look at the practice of hunting seabirds and eggs, and how historically North Atlantic islanders relied on seafowl for food and many other practical uses.

North Atlantic islanders relied on seafowl for food over millennia, broadening their diet by extending limited resources. Birds were roasted when fresh, and salted ones were boiled throughout the year. Feathers had many uses; soft ones for bedding, quills in toys, bright ones for fishing lures. St Kilda’s folk depended on birds like folk elsewhere used fish and seals: islanders made bait from puffins, lamp oil from fulmars, shoes from gannets.

The inhabitants of St Kilda, in the Hebrides, depended on birds more than any other society in Europe. They had to descend the island's terrifying cliffs, their life depending on a rope and their bare feet, to net fulmars and to snare gannets. Birds sustained people for thousands of year - providing food, bedding, thread, footwear, medicine.

Northern and Western islanders caught birds using similar methods – snares, nets, and ropes. For cliff-laying birds, operations were dangerous, and men on the clifftop lowered someone over the precipice on a rope. Cliff fowlers carried a basket for eggs, and birds were tied around the man’s waist. George Low described operations in Foula in 1774: “They never trust much to the rope nor stake. Once they have got footing, they depend more on their own climbing than any rope… Few who make this practice for life die a natural death.” People only targeted particular species, because it was vital to not overexploit resources that humans partly depended on for survival.

People in all the Atlantic islands depended on seabirds for food for centuries. Diverse habitats meant many species were caught: some could be netted on the wing, like auks, guillemots, and puffins. The device used by these Orcadians was identical the one used in Shetland and Faroe.

Gathering birds and their eggs was a seasonal part of every Shetland family's life since ancient times. Depending on local geography, people went off to holms by boat, or went down cliffs by rope. The fowler carried a basket for eggs, and often a pole with a hook to manoeuvre towards a nest.

However, from the 19th century, visitors collected scarcer species for stuffing, and islanders were happy to sell specimens. These depredations affected the rarer species not required for subsistence needs. Eventually, legislation protecting birds was introduced. The only communal fowling left in Britain is the Lewis gannet hunt, protected by law since 1954. Modern threats - habitat loss, pollution, overfishing - pose more harm to birds than fowling did. The Faroese are the only islanders where traditions survive, and annually around 150,000 birds are harvested. Battery hens are cheap, and safe to acquire, but are they more ethical?

Seabirds and people lived in balance, and thousands of eggs were eaten each year. Northern and Western Islanders had largely abandoned harvesting eggs by the time gathering them was banned in Britain in 1954. The Faroese still collect them from the wild for food, but British islanders are largely too genteel now for seafowl eggs, even it was legal!

Listen: Ian Tait will be interviewed for Radio Scotland’s ‘Sunday Morning’ live show on Sunday 31 January at 10.00am, where he will be discussing the Fair Game exhibition and together with a panel discussing what causes society to change its behavior, and how/if it should be changed more.

Find out more: Follow the links to find out about the Between Islands project, Shetland’s new online exhibition, ‘Fair Game.

Related Posts

Shetland Museum closed Saturday (6 Aug) afternoon

Shetland Museum is closing at 2.00pm this Saturday 6 August.

Read more

Da Wadder

The weather is never far from conversation here, and it hasn’t been a great summer. Some good days though, and on July 19 the ...

Read more

Maggie Helen Under Sail

The Maggie Helen was under sail last night for the first time in over 100 years.

Read more


The Soviet Union invaded Finland on 30 November 1940. World opinion at large supported the Finnish cause and they received foreign aid ...

Read more

Temporary diversion at the Museum as the Maggie Helen is on the move

There will be a temporary car park closure and access diversion in place at Hay’s Dock at the Shetland Museum and Archives from the ...

Read more

Land of Straw Art Exhibition

Opening today, Berenice Carrington’s exhibition at the Shetland Museum and Archives focuses on the agricultural cycle of growing ...

Read more

The Laurel

The Shetland Times, 12 October 1907 reported an important event at the Ness. Harry Irvine of Glenfield got a Fifie fishing boat, the ...

Read more

Join the guest list for BBC Radio 4’s Any Questions at Shetland Museum and Archives

It’s your chance to ask a question and influence the debate as BBC Radio 4’s Any Questions is coming to Shetland Museum and ...

Read more

Shetland's jubilations (Part 2)

2022 is the third time in twenty years there’s been a Royal Jubilee, so you might think they come around often. In fact, it’s in ...

Read more

Shetland's jubilations (Part 1)

2022 is the third time in twenty years there’s been a Royal Jubilee, so a body might think they come around often. In fact, it's in ...

Read more

Johnnie Notions Project

We are delighted to announce that we have been awarded funding from The Royal Society to make a film on 18th Century Shetland pioneer, ...

Read more

Hay’s Dock by the Dowry now open

Food and drink is back on the menu at Shetland Museum and Archives, with the much-anticipated opening of ‘Hay’s Dock by the ...

Read more

Crofthouse Museum open for the summer

The Crofthouse Museum at Dunrossness will be opening for the summer season from Sunday 1 May. The site has been closed for the last ...

Read more

Restoration work to begin on Maggie Helen at historic Hay's Dock

This week Shetland Museum and Archives will welcome traditional sail vessel the Swallow to Hay's Dock with its crew of shipwrights ...

Read more

Gunnister Man Coins

Over 70 years after his discovery in a Northmavine peat bog, Gunnister Man continues to intrigue. Last week Shetland Museum curator, ...

Read more